I think this is not the right way to solve the problem.
Pokecommunity is the biggest Pokemon hacking forum around. We all know this. Posting or visiting there is pretty much a necessity if you want more eyes on your work.
The atmosphere there is not ideal. We all know this too. Talking about it won't change it. What will change it? Consistently posting high-quality hacks, tools, and documentation there. Will Pokecommunity ever become a super-high-quality hacking community? No, just like Serebii.net will never have good fanfiction. However, that doesn't mean that everything there is worthless.
Making new forums just increases fragmentation of the already-sparse hacking info on the net. This is counterproductive.
Personally, I used to visit Pokecommunity, make (IMHO) useful and informative posts, and gently nudge people to Twilight Hacking (then later Skeetendo) through signature links and the aforementioned useful posts. I still think that this is the best and most effective approach. The people who care about GSC, who care about making high-quality hacks, who care about writing good documentation -- these people are the ones who will notice that Pokecommunity doesn't have the best information, and will move to better places.
This is simply untrue. Would you call Prism unrecognized? It won hack of the year! The good hacks have plenty of recognition. The good threads get approved and stickied.
As for M3I in particular: I'm not really inclined to visit a site where news posts have fifty comments spamming car insurance.
The forum is done all wrong. When you make a forum, never add a bunch of categories and subcategories and expect to fill them up! Field of Dreams was a movie, not an example to live by. If you make a forum, people will not magically fill it with content. Forums with no posts tend to have no posts forever.
Programming board, 0 posts plus two empty subforums. Fanart board, 2 posts. Fanfics board, 0 posts. Anime board, 6 posts. How about ROM hacking, the supposed focus of the forum? Gen 1 hacking board, 0 posts plus two empty subforums. Gen 2 hacking board, 0 posts plus two empty subforums. Gen 3 hacking board, 5 posts plus one empty subforum. Gen 4 hacking board, 0 posts plus two empty subforums. Why do you expect people to move to a board with no content?
The real way to start a forum is to make a few boards,
fill them with content, and make more boards when you need them. You should have made your board with "General talk" "Gen 1/2" "Gen 3/4" "Video games/Anime"
and nothing else. When those subforums get happenin', people will think "hey, this is an active forum and I like to go here because there's always new content." That makes them post more. That makes more people think it's active, and you get more and more posts and more and more activity. That is how a new forum succeeds.
Free hosting? Ads everywhere? Get real. If you cared about your website you'd pay $10 a year for a good domain name. When the site's owner doesn't make interesting posts, clear out spam, or put any money into a website, why should I even take a second look?
Merging with PHO? Nothing against GC (he's a cool guy), but PHO was only marginally better than Pokecommunity. Its advantage was administrators who cared enough to properly moderate the site. That makes it the best alternative to Pokecommunity I've seen, and I hope it continues to do well. This M3I just isn't of the same class.
I'm deliberately using harsh language here. You propose leaving Pokecommunity, and can't make a competent alternative? If you want people to switch, you need to make your site
flawless. You need to
fill it with cool info nobody else has. You need to make something that's so good it
can't be criticized, because otherwise you will live in obscurity as yet-another-five-minute-forum-setup.